Morgan Front Suspension Bushes

Replacement of Bronze Bushes with Thermoplastic Materials

07 November 2003


A review of alternative materials has been undertaken to confirm the use of plastic materials instead of the classic bronze bushes used in the Morgan front suspension. It is understood that MMC have now converted their bushes to the material Devlon S (from Devol Engineering UK). After some investigation, it seems that there are a number of specialist materials that are formulated for specific applications. A detailed comparison of characteristics between various thermoplastic materials leads to some confusion as each appears to be formulated for a designed for application, eg. road marking, recyclable plastics, chemical protection, bearings, machinery, mining etc.

In particular, two materials have been compared; Devlon S and Vesconite Hi Lube. The exact composition of each material is a closely guarded secret but I did speak to the Vesco Plastics people (Vesconite) inn South Africa who were helpful..as well as the DEVOL company in Scotland.


 
Description
Devlon S
Vesconite Hi Lube
Manufacture
UK
South Africa
Material
UHMW1 Polyethylene
Polyester base
Fillers
Unknown
Teflon fibres
Lubrication
Not required though advised by gomog
Not required, water is good lubricant
Hardness (Shore D)
80
82 (slightly better)
Linear thermal expansion (mm/mm/oC)
1.42 x 10-4
6 x 10-5 (better)
Water absorption
0.1 %
0.5 % (same)


Ultra High Molecular Weight. Could also be a manufactured Nylon with unknown filler. The are many Nylon grades and it is not possible to determine the exact nature of this type.

At this stage, I believe that both materials would be suitable for the bush application but without further confirmation from Devol, I believe that the Vesconite is more suitable for the application. This material is specifically formulated for dirty environments, is able to take shocks, water-resistant, is used in bearings, ship propellor shaft bearings, mining and transport applications, can be machined and welded.

I have used the Vesconite Hi Lube material in the front suspension beshes, as wear blocks between the rear springs and chassis rails and in the sliding rear spring mounts (Series 1 rear suspension).

A bit of information found at various sources on the Internet, including Dow Chemicals, has been added for reference and further confusion.
 

Dictionary Definition of THERMOPLASTIC: -

1. A material that softens when heated and hardens again when cooled having the property of softening or fusing when heated and of hardening and becoming rigid again when cooled.

2.Thermoplastic materials can be remelted and cooled time after time without undergoing any appreciable chemical change.

Dow Chemicals Physical Characteristics: -



1. Abrasion Resistance

Abrasion resistance, tested by ASTM D 1044 procedures, is measured by applying a Taber Abrader with a 250 g weight and a CS 10-F textured abrader to the test specimen for a set number of cycles, and then measuring changes in specimen volume and transparency.

Abrasion Resistance of Selected Thermoplastics table shows typical abrasion resistance values for a number of selected thermoplastics. Lower values equate with greater abrasion resistance.

1 Grams removed after 100 cycles
Material
Abrasion Resistance %1
PE Polyethylene)
4.5x10-3
PP (polypropylene)
4.3x10-3
PC
4.3x10-3
Aceta
4.0x10-3
Nylon 6/6
1.6x10-3
PU
1.5x10-3


 

2.Hardness: -

To measure Rockwell hardness by ASTM D 785 procedures, an indenter is loaded with a minor load, a major load, and then again with the minor load. The increased depth of the impression made on the specimen is then measured. Thus, Rockwell hardness values indicate a material's resistance to surface deformation – thus greater hardness.
 

The Ranking of Selected Thermoplastics by Hardness table shows the relative ranking of major thermoplastics from softest to hardest.
 

Ranking of Selected Thermoplastics by Hardness

 
Ranking
Material
Softest
HDPE (high density polyester)
 
ABS (Acrylonitrile Butadiene Styrene)
 
Polysulfone
 
PBT
 
PC
 
GPPS
 
PET (Polyethylene Terephthalate)
 
Acrylic
 
Nylon 6
Hardest
Thermoplastic Polyimide

3.Coefficient of Friction: -

The coefficient of friction, determined by ASTM D 1894, numerically represents the resistance to movement when moving against another surface. Values are given for both static friction (the limiting friction between surfaces just before motion occurs) and kinetic friction (the friction after motion has occurred). The coefficient of friction is the ratio of the limiting friction to the normal reaction between the moving surfaces.

The Typical Coefficient of Dynamic Friction of Selected Plastics vs. Steel table lists the dynamic coefficient of friction of selected thermoplastics against steel surfaces. The lower the value, the "more slippery" the material.

Typical Coefficient of Dynamic Friction of Selected Plastics vs. Steel

 
Material
Coefficient
PC
0.55
ABS
0.5
SAN
0.5
Nylon
0.4
PMMA
0.4
PS
0.4
PPE
0.35
PP
0.33
HDPE
0.26


The Devol site can be located at -  http://www.devol.com/material/Fdev.htm

Click Design Criteria above and then bushes and bearing and then "properties".

The Vesco site can be located at –  http://www.vesco.com.au/vescoplastics.html

About Plain Bearings, P max, V max, and PV max
 
Sleeve Bearing
 
P max- The maximum load a bearing can carry at 0 rpm.
Formula: Maximum bearing load (psi for inch sizes; N/mm2 for metric) = P max  x  bearing length  x  shaft diameter

To convert psi to N/mm2 , multiply psi value by 0.006894757. To convert N/mm2 to psi, multiply N/mm2 value by 145.032.

V max- The maximum velocity or speed (based on the maximum shaft rpm) that a bearing can carry at light loads. For inch bearings, maximum velocity is stated in surface feet per minute (fpm). For metric bearings, it is meters per second (m/s). To convert fpm to m/s, multiply fpm value by 0.00508. To convert m/s to fpm, multiply m/s value by 196.8504.
 
PV max -Once you've selected a bearing based on P max and V max, use PV max (shown with product listings) as the final check to ensure that the bearing can sustain your combined load and speed requirements. If actual PV is less than PV max, the bearing should fit your application.
 

Bronze Sleeve Bearings

For Shaft Dia. Tolerance
 
For
Shaft Dia.  Tolerance
 
SAE 841
 1/8"-1 1/2" +.000" to -.001"
1 3/4"-2 1/2" +.000" to -.0015"
3" +.000" to -.002"
SAE 660
All ±.0010"
Metric SAE 841
All +.006 to +.024mm
Metric SAE 660
All  ±.0254mm
 
    OD Tolerance
 
OD  Tolerance
 
SAE 841
 1/4"-1 5/8" +.000" to -.001"
1 3/4"-2 3/4" +.000" to -.0015"
3"-3 1/2" +.000" to -.002"
4" +.000" to -.003"
SAE 660
 1/4"-3" +.002" to +.003"
3 1/2"-4" +.003" to +.005"
Metric SAE 841
15-18mm +.028 to +.046mm
19-22mm +.035 to +.056mm
Metric SAE 660
All  +.0508mm to +.0762mm
 
    Length Tolerance
 
Length  Tolerance
 
SAE 841
 1/8"-1 1/2" ±.005"
1 3/4"-3" ±.0075"
4" ±.010"
5"-6" ±.015"
6 1/2" Not rated
SAE 660
All ±.005"
Metric SAE 841
All ±1%
Metric SAE 660
All  ±.1270mm
 
 
SAE 841 Bronze- Similar to Oilite-style bushings with an alloy of copper, tin, and carbon, these porous sintered bronze bearings are vacuum-impregnated with 18-20% SAE-30 oil. Heat created by shaft movement draws the oil to bearing surface. The oil acts as a cushion between the shaft and bearing, reducing wear and increasing resistance to shock loads.
SAE 660 Bronze- An alloy of copper, tin, lead, and zinc, these nonporous bearings resist shock loads and wear. High-temperature lubricants are recommended over 250° F.
Bearing Material  Temperature Range  For Shaft Hardness  Pmax  Vmax  PVmax
SAE 841 10° to 220°F  Medium and up  2,000  1,200  50,000
SAE 660 10° to 450°F  Medium and up  4,000  750  75,000
Metric SAE 841 10° to 220°F  Medium and up  13.79  6.10  1.75
Metric SAE 660 10° to 450°F  Medium and up  27.58  3.81  2.7